Speakers Recently Auditioned
My standard evaluation discs and tracks are:
'Blackbird', Double White, The Beatles
'Tin Pan Alley', Couldn't Stand the Weather, Stevie Ray Vaughan
'Two Roads', Two Roads, Phil Manning
'Lily was Here', Lily was Here Soundtrack, David A Stewart
'Jest Smoochin'', Austin Backalley Blue, Sweetman & South Side Groove Kings
'Fields of Gold', Live at Blues Alley, Eva Cassidy
The speaker models and my initial listening impressions are documented below. Remember YMMV!
Martin Logan Ascent (I think) - I have never been a real ML fan, and listening to this speaker with McIntosh power didn't do it for me either. Excellent mid range but the sound never really appeals as entertaining (or foot tapping).
B&W 802 (non diamond) - This speaker seems to do everything OK, if only it cost 50% less. Not spectacular at anything however.
Wilson Audio Sophia (Mk 2) - Extremely crisp highs and deep lows but thin in the mid-range I felt. Also the speaker had a strange tonal balance. 'Blackbird' sounded like John Lennon was singing with a head cold, when it should sound like a healthy Paul Mac! Excellent build quality though but at a very high-end price.
Dynaudio
Confidence 2 & 4 - The C2's were a bit
bland for my taste, but the C4's were certainly a cut
above the C2. I particularly enjoyed the bass, sound
stage and presence of this monster. Big and quirky
looks results in a questionable Wife Acceptance
Factor however!
Legend Acoustics Big Reds - A great
concept IMHO and an extremely well constructed
speaker system. A good all round performer at a
realistic price. The demo included the DEQX speaker
management and room calibration device which
logically appeals but I am sure is extremely complex
to understand, configure and exploit.
Martin Logan
Depth Sub Woofer - Well built and attractive
for a sub (not just a 'box') and a sound that was
solid and musical. Got to test this at home but was
not really comfortable with the 'passive' RCA
splitter I used to connect the sub to the Wadia. A
powered splitter should get me over this limitation.
I probably needed to spend more time 'tuning' the
Depth for my room.
In summary, good speakers
all, but none of the above really did it for me at
first listen, but I reserve the right to re-visit,
especially the Big Reds and the ML Depth. I should
however add that my 'ears' are tuned to tube
amplification and all the above (except the ML sub)
were tested with solid state gear.
To close I would like to recognise the professional
attention and service I received while auditioning
the above at Secher Audio, Tivoli Hi Fi, Carlton
Audio Visual and Frankston Hi Fi. Thanks guys!